Did the Blackhawks make a mistake by trading Kirby Dach?

Did the Hawks make a mistake by trading Kirby Dach? originally appeared on NBC Sports Chicago

For the first time since being traded by the Blackhawks in the offseason, Kirby Dach will return to the United Center on Friday to face the team that drafted him with the No. 3 overall pick in 2019.

Dach is off to a strong start with the Montreal Canadiens. He has 17 points (four goals, 13 assists) through 20 games and is on pace for 69 points, which would shatter his previous career-high of 26.

This begs the question: Did the Blackhawks make a mistake by trading Dach? It would be knee-jerky to say yes at this current moment, and I actually think this trade could end up being a win-win for both parties.

For one, Dach probably needed the change of scenery as much as the Blackhawks were looking to shake up their roster. He put a ton of pressure on himself here in Chicago to live up to being the third overall selection and you could tell it weighed on him when things weren’t going right.

It also felt like he was still trying to figure out what kind of player he should be at the NHL level: an offensive, flashy-type center like Jack Eichel or a dependable two-way shutdown-type center like Jonathan Toews? The trade gave Dach an opportunity to reset mentally and have a fresh start in Montreal, and no question you can see him playing looser so far because of it.

It’s also worth pointing out that Dach is playing on the wing alongside Nick Suzuki. He might project to be a center in the long term, but it’s no slamdunk.

I would argue that the Blackhawks didn’t really “give up” on Dach, per se. They knew what his ceiling could be and that he was a coveted asset around the league. Who wouldn’t want a 21-year-old 6-foot-4, 197-pound two-way player with upside who’s just scratching the surface in the NHL?

The Blackhawks more so wanted to change the makeup of their team, from top to bottom. GM Kyle Davidson repeatedly talked about wanting to rebuild his roster with “up-tempo speed players that play high-motor hockey,” especially up the middle, and Dach has more of a power-forward-type skillset.

Story continues

So who did the Blackhawks take with the No. 13 overall pick they acquired from Montreal for Dach? Frank Nazar, a 5-foot-10, 180-pound center who’s arguably the fastest player in his draft class and has a high compete level. Check and check.

Unfortunately for Chicago, Nazar has been sidelined with an injury that could keep him out of the lineup for his entire freshman season at Michigan, but the organization remains high on him.

It’s also important to note that the Blackhawks received an additional third-round pick in the Dach trade. You could probably even count it as a late second-rounder because it was the very first pick of the third round at No. 66 overall. That’s where the Blackhawks drafted Gavin Hayes, a 6-foot-2, 177-pound right-handed shot winger who plays a 200-foot game. He’s off to an encouraging start with the OHL’s Flint Firebirds, where he has 21 points (eight goals, 13 assists) in 22 games.

At this point, it’s way too early to judge which team won the trade. There certainly isn’t a loser right now either. The Canadiens feel they got a potential core player in Dach while the Blackhawks feel they got a potential speedy top-six center in Nazar and a solid-skating, competitive two-way winger in Greene, two prospects who fit the mold of the Blackhawks’ new identity.

Click here to subscribe to the Blackhawks Talk Podcast for free.

Download

Download MyTeams Today!